The Federal Constitutional Court dismissed the lawsuits filed by three telecommunications companies against the special termination right for long-term television contracts, which has since expired. As the Karlsruhe judges communicated on Monday, the infringement on the property rights of the network operators constitutes a proportionate and acceptable content and limitation provision and does not violate the prohibition of retroactivity. The infringement on professional freedom and general freedom of action is also justified. The companies had complained that the special termination right violated their fundamental rights to property and professional freedom. They also cited a violation of the protection of expectations and a breach of the prohibition of retroactivity. The special termination right, enshrined in the Telecommunications Act, allowed contract parties to end agreements without observing a notice period, provided that no different regulation was established. The background of the special termination right is an amendment to the Operating Costs Ordinance from December 2021, which largely eliminated the ability to transfer the costs for services to tenants. This regulation of the Operating Costs Ordinance, which was often referred to by landlords as a utility cost privilege, originated in the 1970s. The new regulation was intended to promote competition and give tenants more freedom of choice. The Federal Constitutional Court now ruled that the legislator has considerable scope for design when restructuring complex regulatory systems and that the interests of the network operators were sufficiently considered.

Mixed

