Renowned economists and energy researchers warn of significant additional costs for the federal budget due to the planned reform of the Renewable Energy Sources Act (EEG). The government fractions of the Union and SPD should neither massively expand biomass subsidies nor introduce a permanent feed-in tariff for small solar systems, write 26 scientists in a joint submission in the FAZ (Tuesday edition).
Among the signatories are, besides the initiator and energy economist Lion Hirth, Marc Oliver Bettzüge, Ottmar Edenhofer, Gabriel Felbermayr, Clemens Fuest, Veronika Grimm, Monika Schnitzer, and Moritz Schularick. They criticize that an estimate suggests alone biogas will incur around 50 billion euros in additional expenditures over two decades if the tenders are fully utilized-and this is compared to the government draft, which already entailed additional costs of around 20 billion euros for biogas compared to the status quo. Further billions would be added for small solar systems.
According to the authors, the ongoing negotiations are evolving into a compromise that envisions permanent subsidies for small solar systems and an expansion of biogas promotion. Nothing has been decided yet. The signatories quantify the potential additional expenditures for biogas alone at around 50 billion euros over two decades-compared to the government draft and assuming the planned tenders are fully utilized. Further billions would be added for small solar systems.
The economists criticize that this government, which campaigned on reducing subsidies, now threatens the opposite. Instead of easing the burden on the budget, it would be catering to particular interests. Instead of consistently relying on the cheapest electricity generation, it would be keeping expensive facilities operational with billions of euros.
The authors criticize that small solar roof systems and biogas systems belong to the most expensive electricity generation technologies. While biogas is storable and can be used when there is insufficient wind and sunshine, many systems have run previously even when enough cheaper electricity was available. They therefore view the planned relaxation of requirements for smaller systems critically. The economists demand no massive expansion of biomass subsidies and no permanent feed-in tariff for small solar systems. It is not too late for this.


