A period of nine months has passed since the position of President at Germany’s Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution (BfV), the domestic intelligence agency, became vacant, prompting increasing commentary from within the security establishment. Currently, the agency is being jointly led in an interim capacity by Vice Presidents Silke Willems and Sinan Selen.
Former BfV President Hansjörg Geiger expressed surprise at the length of the vacancy, stating to “Welt am Sonntag” that while he believes the current interim leadership is performing well, the absence of a permanent President is notable. The previous President, Thomas Haldenwang, stepped down in November of last year after unsuccessfully contesting a seat in the Bundestag.
One official familiar with the BfV’s operations voiced substantial concern regarding the prolonged vacancy, describing it as deeply unsettling, particularly in light of existing security challenges. This individual contends the agency lacks visible leadership and a clear strategic direction, with the Vice Presidents lacking sufficient authority to effectively advocate for the BfV’s needs regarding personnel, funding and legislative matters.
A former head of a state-level intelligence agency echoed these concerns, characterizing the situation as unprecedented in the history of the Federal Republic. They highlighted the potential reputational damage to the BfV, which is intensifying with each passing week.
Government sources indicate ongoing negotiations within the ruling coalition regarding a replacement. The Federal Ministry of the Interior stated it will announce a decision in due course, but declined to comment on the timeline or the selection process.
Stephan Kramer, head of the Thuringia state office for the protection of the constitution, offered a perspective of understanding regarding the careful deliberations, suggesting that prioritizing quality over speed is paramount in such a critical appointment.
The appointment requires consideration of the governing coalition partner, the SPD. Their security policy representatives have remained circumspect. Sebastian Fiedler, the SPD’s spokesperson on internal affairs, acknowledged the new government is still in its initial months and will reach a decision soon. Sonja Eichwede, a member of the parliamentary control committee responsible for overseeing intelligence agencies, affirmed the BfV’s continued operational capacity, praising the contributions made by the Vice Presidents.
