The remarks of CDU leader Friedrich Merz regarding Brazil have ignited a firestorm of criticism within Germany, with the SPD accusing him of fueling damaging stereotypes and exacerbating existing tensions between Europe and South America. Isabel Cademartori, SPD parliamentarian and a native of Chile, condemned Merz’s comments as particularly ill-timed, arguing they risk undermining efforts to build a more equitable partnership with Brazil and the wider region.
During a recent trade conference in Berlin, Merz recounted an anecdote from his trip to Belém for the World Climate Conference, claiming he inquired amongst journalists about their desire to remain in Brazil. His assertion that no one raised their hand and that the sentiment appeared to be a collective relief at returning to Germany, has been widely interpreted as dismissive and patronizing.
Cademartori sharply criticized the statement, highlighting a growing perception in South America, particularly intensified by the confrontational policies of former U.S. President Donald Trump, that the West operates with an aggressive and imperialistic agenda. She argued that a concerted “charm offensive” from Europe is now essential to demonstrate genuine partnership and mutual respect. This includes accelerating progress on the stalled Mercosur trade agreement.
The SPD parliamentarian urged Chancellor Scholz to swiftly and decisively address the negative impression created by Merz’s remarks. She proposed concrete actions, including a significant German contribution to the Amazon Fund and a commitment to fulfill climate protection agreements reached at recent COP conferences, as immediate steps toward repairing the damage and rebuilding trust. The incident underscores a broader challenge for European policymakers: navigating a complex geopolitical landscape marked by shifting perceptions and the need for a more nuanced and respectful approach towards its international partners.
